I like a combination of creamy American cheese and extra-sharp cheddar, but feel free to substitute jack cheese or Gruyère for the cheddar. A combination of cheeses adds a little more dimension to the flavor. Adding all the milk at once will cause clumps. This allows the sauce to be creamy smooth. Add the milk to the roux in small additions at first, stirring each time.The key is to choose a small pasta with good crannies. Less common, but still widely-available, shapes like radiatore and riccioli also make an excellent mac and cheese. Best choices include elbow macaroni (of course) and medium shells. The Best Creamy Macaroni And Cheese With Evaporated Milk Recipes on Yummly Creamy Macaroni And Cheese, Creamy Macaroni And Cheese, Creamy Macaroni And. Pay close attention to the pasta, and cook it only until a minute under al dente.Cook over low heat, stirring constantly until cheese begins to melt. Add cheddar cheese and American cheese stir. Whisk together evaporated milk, eggs, mustard and pepper in medium bowl. In the recipe notes below, you’ll learn how.Įasy Stovetop Mac and Cheese: Recipe Notes Prepare pasta according to package directions. Flaccid and mushy from overcooked pastaīad macaroni and cheese usually results from some combination of choosing cheeses that easily separate, overcooking the pasta, or cooking the macaroni and cheese at too high of a temperature.īut well-made mac and cheese tastes creamy, rich, and highly cheesy, with pasta that is just on the soft side of al dente.Elements of a Great Easy Stovetop Mac and CheeseĪnyone who has been unfortunate enough to encounter bad mac and cheese knows what macaroni and cheese should not be: This recipe uses a white sauce as a base, before melting into it a goodly amount of American and sharp cheddar cheeses. dijon mustard 2 cups extra-sharp cheddar. Most recipes use either evaporated milk or an easy white sauce. all-purpose flour 1 (10 oz) can evaporated milk 1 cup milk 1 tsp. There is more than one way to make a great macaroni and cheese, starting with the white sauce. Add the cheese in batches to the noodles and use a wooden spoon to stir and combine until creamy. Baked mac and cheese is fantastic as well (especially when topped with buttered breadcrumbs), but this stovetop mac and cheese comes together in about 20 minutes from start to finish, and makes an indulgent, classic side dish. Instructions In a medium saucepan, add the noodles, butter, water, evaporated milk, and salt. Comfort food does not get better than this.Ĭomfort food doesn’t get much better than this homemade easy stovetop mac and cheese recipe, ready in about 20 minutes.Ĭomfort food doesn’t get much better than this easy, creamy homemade stovetop mac and cheese recipe.